From Abbub@21:2/145 to All on Monday, May 08, 2023 08:14:35
Anybody watching the 'Silo' show on Apple TV? Based on Hugh Howie's 'Wool' books? I remember enjoying the books when I read them a few years back. It'll be interesting to see how they translate to television. I'm not sure who's working on it, but I'm a *little* wary because I thought the translation from book to TV for the Foundation series that Apple TV had was pretty meh.
* Origin: Telnet: bbs.WalledCTTY.com:1989 - Fort Collins, CO USA (21:2/145)
From massive@21:3/178 to Abbub on Tuesday, May 09, 2023 18:24:02
Ok, wow, I loved Wool when it was coming out - I'm going to check this out tonight and then get back with some thoughts. Thanks for the tip!
From massive@21:3/178 to Abbub on Tuesday, May 09, 2023 20:44:48
ok, watched the first episode.
I have to say, pretty faithful from what I recall and not bad pacing.
What I didn't like:
1. The central stair for the Silo - the real one was wrapped around
the outside and the silo was much smaller than the show
2. Paper - paper was like gold and they even mention that but then they casually use paper for pads and notes and to wrap food
3. Space - there is just way too much space in the show, but ok
What I did like:
1. Faithfullness to the story - it's following it pretty well
2. Runners - the runners are there moving stuff up and down
3. Size - that it takes a day to get to the lowest levels